Re-Roofing Vs. Roof Restoration: the Ultimate Comparison Gallery

When it comes to addressing aging or damaged roofs, property owners are faced with the decision between re-roofing and roof restoration.

Each option comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages, making it crucial to carefully evaluate specific needs and circumstances.

This article provides a comprehensive comparison between re-roofing and roof restoration, examining factors such as material reliability, installation efficiency, lifespan limitations, and weather considerations.

By offering real-life examples and expert insights, readers will gain practical guidance in navigating these complex roofing endeavors.

Pros of Re-roofing

Re-roofing offers several advantages for homeowners and contractors seeking a reliable and accessible solution for roof replacement.

The durability of re-roofing materials ensures long-lasting protection for the structure.

Additionally, re-roofing is cost-effective as it eliminates the need for a complete roof replacement.

The aesthetic appeal of re-roofing options allows homeowners to enhance the overall look of their property.

Furthermore, re-roofing requires minimal maintenance, making it a convenient choice.

Lastly, re-roofing has a positive environmental impact by reducing waste and conserving resources.

Cons of Re-roofing

One drawback of re-roofing is the limited lifespan of built-up roofing (BUR) and single-ply roofing materials. These roofing options have certain disadvantages and limitations that should be considered. Here are some key points to note:

  • Single-ply roofs typically last 25-30 years, while the lifespan of built-up roofing can vary.
  • Regulatory standards for built-up roofing, as well as TPO and PVC roofing, are not mandatory, which can pose challenges in terms of quality control.
  • Repair requirements for BUR and single-ply roofs often involve complete removal of the damaged section, rather than patching up.
  • Major damages to BUR and single-ply roofing cannot be easily repaired and may require more extensive measures.
  • It is important to be aware of the repair and maintenance needs associated with these roofing materials to ensure their longevity.

Pros of Roof Restoration

Roof restoration offers numerous advantages for property owners looking to enhance the longevity and performance of their roofs. Here are some of the benefits of roof restoration:

Extends the lifespan of the roofIncreases the value of the propertyUtilizes advanced roofing materials and methods
Improves energy efficiencyReduces the need for costly repairs in the futureIncorporates innovative technologies
Enhances the appearance of the roofProvides protection against leaks and water damageEnsures long-lasting durability

Cons of Roof Restoration

There are several drawbacks to consider when it comes to roof restoration. These include:

  • Roof restoration challenges: Restoring a roof can be a complex process that requires careful planning and execution.
  • Winter interference: Roof restoration can be challenging during winter due to snow and freezing temperatures.
  • Weather conditions impact: Inclement weather can impact the progress of a roof restoration project.
  • Existing roof consideration: The condition of the existing roof must be carefully evaluated before restoration can take place.
  • Weak foundations: Weak or damaged foundations may require additional improvements before a successful restoration can be achieved.

Benefits of Metal Roofing Restoration

Metal roofing restoration offers numerous benefits that make it a superior choice for roof repair and rejuvenation. Here are some key advantages:

Cost SavingsMetal roofing restoration is a cost-effective option compared to complete roof replacement. It eliminates the need for tearing off the existing roof, saving on labor and disposal costs.
Increased DurabilityRestoring a metal roof extends its lifespan by repairing any damage, reinforcing weak areas, and applying protective coatings. This enhances the roof’s durability and ensures long-term performance.
Energy EfficiencyMetal roofs can be coated with reflective coatings, reducing heat transfer and improving energy efficiency. This helps to lower cooling costs and creates a more comfortable indoor environment.
Environmental BenefitsRoof restoration reduces waste by eliminating the need for new materials and reducing landfill impact. Metal roofs are also recyclable, making them an environmentally friendly choice.
Aesthetic EnhancementsRestoring a metal roof allows for aesthetic enhancements, such as changing the color or adding a new finish. This can improve the overall appearance of a building and enhance its curb appeal.

Preventing Waste Roofing Materials

To minimize waste in roofing projects, careful consideration of material usage and disposal methods is essential. Sustainable practices can be implemented to reduce the environmental impact and landfill reduction. Here are some ways to prevent waste roofing materials:

  • Utilize accurate measurements and calculations to order the right amount of materials.
  • Opt for recycling options for old roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles or metal panels.
  • Implement proper storage and handling techniques to prevent damage and waste.
  • Explore opportunities for reusing salvaged materials in future projects.
  • Partner with local recycling facilities to ensure responsible disposal of waste materials.

SPF Vs. Tri-Thermal Roofing

When comparing re-roofing and roof restoration, one important aspect to consider is the difference between SPF and Tri-Thermal roofing.

In terms of energy efficiency, SPF roofing provides excellent insulation properties, reducing heating and cooling costs. However, Tri-Thermal roofing also offers energy efficiency benefits due to its reflective surface.

In terms of cost analysis, SPF roofing tends to have a higher upfront cost but lower maintenance requirements, while Tri-Thermal roofing may have a lower initial cost but higher maintenance expenses.

Durability factors vary, with SPF roofing being highly resistant to leaks and Tri-Thermal roofing offering strong resistance against weather elements.

Maintenance requirements for SPF roofing include periodic inspections and reapplication of protective coatings, while Tri-Thermal roofing may require occasional repairs.

When considering the environmental impact, SPF roofing uses chemicals during installation but provides energy savings, while Tri-Thermal roofing is recyclable but may require additional waste disposal during installation.

Compelling Reasons for Metal Roof Restoration

With its numerous benefits and cost-effective solutions, metal roof restoration stands out as a compelling choice for preserving and enhancing the longevity of commercial roofs.

Here are some compelling reasons why metal roof restoration is worth considering:

  • Cost-effectiveness: Metal roof restoration is a cost-effective alternative to roof replacement, as it eliminates the need for complete tear-off and installation of a new roof.
  • Durability advantages: Metal roofs are known for their durability, and restoration can further strengthen and extend their lifespan.
  • Energy efficiency benefits: Metal roof restoration can improve the energy efficiency of the building by reducing heat transfer and lowering cooling costs.
  • Long-term savings: By restoring a metal roof, businesses can avoid the high costs associated with frequent repairs or premature roof replacement.
  • Environmental sustainability: Metal roof restoration is an environmentally friendly option, as it reduces waste by utilizing the existing roof and decreases the demand for new roofing materials.


In conclusion, both re-roofing and roof restoration have their own advantages and disadvantages, and property owners should carefully consider their specific needs and circumstances before making a decision.

Re-roofing offers the benefit of a brand-new roof with a longer lifespan, but it can be more expensive and time-consuming.

On the other hand, roof restoration can be a cost-effective option that extends the lifespan of the existing roof, but it may not be suitable for roofs with severe damage.

Ultimately, the choice between re-roofing and roof restoration depends on the individual circumstances and preferences of the property owner.

Request a free quote

Roofing & exterior renovation services

Request a Quote

Request a Quote